When news broke that Amazon might start listing tariff costs on some of its product pages, it looked like a bold step toward pricing transparency. Within hours, it became a political flashpoint and a case study in how external pressures can shape, or shatter, customer experience (CX) strategies. It has sparked a wider conversation not just about trade policy, but about trust, transparency and the changing expectations of customers in politically charged times.
Last week, a report by Punchbowl News suggested that Amazon’s budget-focused storefront, Amazon Haul was considering showing the costs added to products as a result of President Trump’s sweeping new tariffs. But after a personal phone call from Trump to Amazon founder Jeff Bezos and a public rebuke from the White House, the company quickly clarified it would not be moving forward with the plan.
“This was never approved and is not going to happen,” Amazon spokesperson Tim Doyle stated, shortly after White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt condemned the potential move as “a hostile and political act.”
This is a crescendo in an ongoing back-and-forth between Bezos and Trump. In his first term, Trump took issue at the damage he said Amazon did to small businesses and Bezos' management of the Washington Post newspaper, which had won awards for its investigative reporting on Trump's relationship to Russia. When Trump won a second term, Bezos extended an olive branch by dining with the president and donating $1 million to the Trump inauguration before joining other tech billionaires on stage on Inauguration Day. Bezos also took steps that journalists say curbed the Washington Post's coverage of the White House, according to USA Today.
While the political drama has dominated headlines, the underlying issue has significant implications for CX professionals: should businesses be more transparent with consumers about external cost pressures even when doing so invites political consequences?
The case for transparency
For customers, pricing transparency builds trust. When companies explain the forces behind rising costs, whether it’s supply chain issues, inflation, or in this case, tariffs, customers are more likely to feel respected and less likely to blame the brand unfairly.
In fact, competitors like Shein and Temu have already begun factoring tariff disclosures into their pricing models, offering customers a clearer view of where their money is going. This not only fosters trust but differentiates them in a crowded, price-sensitive market.
“Consumers today expect honesty,” said CX strategist Dana Lin. “They’re savvy enough to understand that prices go up. What frustrates them is not knowing why.”
Amazon’s initial internal discussions around showing tariff costs appeared to align with that expectation. But once the political fallout began, the company opted to keep those details behind the scenes.
Amazon tariff debate: the political trade-off
By backing away from transparency, Amazon avoided a sustained confrontation with the Trump administration - an especially sensitive issue given Bezos’s historically complex relationship with Trump. But, in doing so, it may have weakened a key pillar of modern CX: openness.
“Silence is a decision too,” said Lin. “And when companies don’t explain pricing shifts, they leave the door open for misinterpretation or mistrust.”
Amazon CEO Andy Jassy has already acknowledged that the company’s sellers - who account for more than 60 percent of its marketplace - will likely raise prices in response to the 145 percent China tariffs. Yet without visible explanations, customers may not distinguish between government-imposed fees and retailer markups.
This latest debacle puts the argument about Trump's war on consumer protection in the spotlight again. The Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), which is led by entrepreneur Elon Musk, recently dismantled the Consumer Financial Protection Board (CFPB).
Quick links:
- M&S cyber attack exposes gap in CX strategy
- Amazon CEO: "AI is reinventing CX"
- JPMorgan Chase sues customers for fraud
[inlinead-1]